# TWO MOONS, TWO DEATH STARS AND THE ULTIMATE CON EXPOSED ## THE MOONS ARE IS THE DEATH STAR ### BY NATHAN TABOR --- # THE BOOK ## I AM JOHN NATHAN TABOR Since 8/29/1973 and before. I knew God before He knew ME!!! Be safe and watch out for normal people. I am not asking anybody to hand me an answer wrapped up in a pretty little box. I have been asking them to open the damn box and show me what is inside. The plans. The budgets. The dates. The original words. The contracts. The instruments. The things they built and the things they wrote down. Not a spokesperson's explanation of what somebody is supposed to think about those things. I look at attributes, characteristics and functionalities. An object can be round and still be different from another round object. A thing called a balloon can measure the weather, carry an instrument, reflect a signal or serve a military program. I know that. That is exactly why I want to look at the thing instead of letting a label think for me. And I am going to start with the most ordinary thing imaginable. A weather balloon. You hear the words *weather balloon* and you picture something floating away from a man in a field. White rubber. String. A little box hanging underneath. Nothing to see here, folks. That's how a label works: it gives your mind a stopping place before you have taken the thing apart. Now I am going to ask a question. WHAT DOES IT DO? And then another. WHAT ELSE DID THEY MAKE IT DO? If those questions bother anybody, I haven't even gotten started. --- # PART ONE — LOOK UP ## CHAPTER ONE — THE WEATHER BALLOON Let me show you something so simple that everybody can look right at it and miss the point. The National Weather Service sends up balloons with radiosondes. That is their word. A radiosonde is an instrument package. It measures temperature, humidity and pressure as it climbs. Its position can be tracked to calculate the wind. Its radio sends that information back down. A balloon you could see from the ground is carrying an instrument you might not recognize at all. There is your first lesson. THE BALLOON IS NOT THE WHOLE MACHINE. And the machine is not explained by calling it a balloon. The National Weather Service describes an ascent that can pass 115,000 feet. The gas expands as the pressure decreases. The balloon grows, eventually bursts, and the instrument comes down by parachute. Launches happen routinely around the world. Some people have seen them. Most people have lived their whole lives without thinking about them twice. I am not interested in making an ordinary weather balloon into something it isn't. I am interested in refusing to make it less than what it is. There is a gas envelope. There is a payload. There is radio equipment. There is a receiving station. There are measurements. There are people who operate the whole damn thing. Now change the payload. Same sky. Different job. Now change the mission. Same word on the outside. Different system underneath it. Now stop telling me the label answers the question. A person who wants to understand something does not stop at the name on the box. Open the box. Follow the wires. Follow the signal. Find the receiving station. Find the people who ordered it built. Follow the money that paid for it. That is not magic. That is common sense. And common sense is exactly where this book begins. ## CHAPTER TWO — THE BALLOONS THE MILITARY DIDN'T PUT ON THE WEATHER REPORT Now that we have a weather balloon, let's keep the balloon and change the purpose. PROJECT MOGUL. The United States ran a classified high-altitude balloon program in the 1940s. The mission involved instruments intended to help detect Soviet nuclear activity. The government did not advertise every detail while the work was under way. Years later, its own reports discussed the program in connection with the government's explanation of debris found near Roswell, New Mexico, in 1947. There is no need for me to invent that sentence. Their records put those words together. CLASSIFIED. BALLOON. MILITARY. INSTRUMENT. NUCLEAR. Put those five words on the same page, because the government already did. It does not turn every balloon into a secret operation. It tells you something much more useful: the same general technology can be put to different purposes, including purposes the public is not told about at the time. You can argue about somebody's theory all day long. You cannot make the actual historical existence of a classified balloon program disappear by laughing at the word *balloon*. So I am not laughing. I am looking. Look at the payload. Look at the altitude. Look at the receiver. Look at the year. Look at who issued the contract. Look at the name that appears on the government page, then read the page instead of letting somebody paraphrase it for you. The point isn't that I know every operation hidden behind every name. The point is that names are not operations. A document can tell you what was ordered. A test record can tell you what was tried. A flight log can tell you what flew. A payment record can tell you what somebody bought. Those are different facts, and I want all of them standing on their own feet. NOT ONE OF THEM HIDING BEHIND THE OTHER. ## CHAPTER THREE — THE GIANT BALL NASA PUT INTO ORBIT Now here comes one of my favorite pieces of their own history. NASA put a giant balloon into orbit. Not a five-foot weather balloon with a radiosonde dangling below it. A one-hundred-foot-diameter Mylar sphere coated to reflect radio signals. Echo 1A. Launched August 12, 1960. ONE HUNDRED FEET. ROUND. REFLECTIVE. ARTIFICIAL. ORBITING EARTH. NASA called the project Echo. NASA's own account described a giant metal balloon in orbit used to bounce signals from one part of the world to another. The receiving stations, their locations and the communications experiments appear in the technical records. The balloon was the reflector. Other equipment did the transmitting and receiving. That means the whole system mattered. The object up above. The signal sent from below. The station listening somewhere else. The geometry between them. The people who designed it. The money that built it. Do you see why I keep saying attributes, characteristics and functionalities? Because if I had told somebody, without giving the NASA date, that the United States put a giant shiny ball in the sky to bounce communications around the Earth, somebody would have called it a crazy story. Then I open NASA's own history. And there it is. I do not need to dress it up. It is interesting enough with the numbers left exactly where they belong. NASA's records call it a passive communications satellite. Engineers at Langley developed the balloon concept, Goddard managed the project, and communications work involved JPL and Bell Laboratories. Those names are part of the record too. I do not have to pretend one office did everybody's work. But I am not going to let a few different organizational names make the whole space race disappear from the same period of history. Huntsville, the Army Ballistic Missile Agency, NASA, military rocketry and orbital communications were all part of a fast-moving technological world. The dates connect. The institutions connect. The capabilities connect. What they actually built must be established by what they actually built, not by what anybody wants the reader to imagine. And that is where the next set of plans gets mighty interesting. ## CHAPTER FOUR — REDSTONE ARSENAL DIDN'T NEED HOLLYWOOD TO THINK ABOUT THE MOON Let's go back to 1959. Before anybody turned a lunar military base into something you could point to on a movie screen, the United States Army put one on paper. PROJECT HORIZON. A U.S. Army Study for the Establishment of a Lunar Military Outpost. That is the real title of the June 8, 1959 study. The Army Ballistic Missile Agency conducted it. Wernher von Braun appointed Heinz-Hermann Koelle to lead the project work. It examined the supplies, rockets, operations, structures, crews and logistical requirements of putting a military outpost on the Moon. It did not consist of two drunk fellows saying, 'Wouldn't it be cool if we built something up there?' It contained actual engineering planning. The Army's own retrospective describes seventy-five Saturn II rockets for initial construction material and equipment and sixty-four rockets a year for support. It describes nuclear power, living quarters, storage, laboratories, communications, recreation, a hospital and modules protected by lunar material. In other words, the Army had already thought about the people, their food, their water, their power and where the hell they were supposed to sleep. ABOVE AND BELOW. A structure on the surface. A protected interior. A logistics chain running all the way back to Earth. Now that is the kind of paper I want to read. I have spoken about Redstone plans and budgets. A plan has a date and a name and a sheet and a purpose. A budget has numbers. An organization has people assigned to work. Those details matter more to me than a thousand polished explanations from somebody who hasn't opened the first folder. The Army record says Project Horizon remained a feasibility study. Fine. Let that sentence stand in the record alongside all the extraordinary details of the study itself. I will not call a proposed base a completed base simply because I like the concept. And I will not make the actual proposal disappear simply because someone tells me it stayed on paper. BOTH FACTS STAY. The study existed. The military purpose existed. The engineering questions existed. And Redstone was part of that history. Anybody who claims there was no serious military planning for a lunar outpost has a date to look up now. June 8, 1959. ## CHAPTER FIVE — THE PEOPLE UNDER THE GROUND Now put the Moon on one side of your mind and the Earth on the other. Do not mash them together. Look at the same engineering problem from both ends. How do you keep people alive when the environment outside can kill them? How do you protect communications? How do you get water, air, power and supplies into a protected place? How do you keep operating when something goes wrong above ground? The government did not wait on a science-fiction movie to ask any of those questions. GREENBRIER. A resort in West Virginia. A public building with an extraordinary second purpose. During the Cold War, the U.S. government secretly built a relocation facility for Congress beneath the resort's expansion. People came and went without realizing what was below. The facility eventually became public knowledge in 1992. That is their history, not something I dreamed up. CAMP CENTURY. The U.S. Army constructed a facility in Greenland beneath the ice. A place with tunnels, sleeping spaces, scientific work and power. The Army also considered a larger missile network called Project Iceworm. A built camp and a much bigger proposed system are two different entries in the ledger; both belong in the story of what the government was preparing for. THULE. An early-warning radar installation in Greenland. Part of a Cold War system designed to notice incoming threats and send information to decision-makers before time ran out. Look at the world they were designing: places above, places below, places at the edge of the ice, places that talked to other places, and machines trying to see what human beings couldn't see with their own eyes. That is not one secret world map I have to invent. Those are real chapters of the Cold War with different dates and different functions. Now ask what an engineer would compare when designing such systems. Power. Communications. Protection. Redundancy. Supply. Distance. Time. SAME QUESTIONS. DIFFERENT LOCATIONS. The mistake is not comparing them. The mistake would be claiming two separate installations are the same installation without a document connecting them. So keep the documents in the right folders, and keep reading. ## CHAPTER SIX — THE MOON ALARM THAT ACTUALLY REACHED THE MILITARY Here is a remarkable sentence from the military record. On October 5, 1960, radar echoes from the Moon appeared in the Thule warning system and were initially identified as a potential missile threat. The alarm was treated as false. Investigators traced it to reflections from the Moon, and procedures were changed to filter out the problem. THE MOON SHOWED UP ON A MILITARY WARNING SYSTEM. Not as a Hollywood special effect. As a real radar return, in a real military system, at a real moment in history. The declassified history of strategic warning records it. The date and the explanation are there. Now think about the connection to Project Echo in that same year. NASA was deliberately bouncing radio signals off an artificial reflective satellite. The military was using radar to watch for missiles, and a lunar reflection caused a false alarm. Two systems. Different missions. The same physical phenomenon of signals traveling through space and reflecting from objects. It matters that the objects and systems are not identical. It also matters that a person looking up at the sky would never know all of that from the appearance of a light overhead. That is exactly why I keep asking for the underlying record. What bounced? What was transmitted? What was received? Who saw the return? What conclusion did the operators draw? What did the later investigation report? Their documents answer specific questions. Those answers give us a way to test other questions without inventing the answers in advance. And I am not finished asking. --- # PART TWO — THE FAMILY, THE ARSENAL, THE WORD ## CHAPTER SEVEN — OPAL PHILLIPS TABOR Let me bring this back to a human being instead of an acronym. OPAL PHILLIPS TABOR. My grandma. I grew up a Tabor. Redstone Arsenal was not a little name in some history book to me. Huntsville, Madison County, Owens Cross Roads, the people who lived and worked there—that was my world. I told the story of Grandma Opal and the Moon because I remembered it. And I told the joke because the joke was hers. Here are my original words: > Opal Phillips Tabor told me the Moon is the Death Star built by the Redstone Arsenal - my grandmother was not a liar ... HAHA ... unless the lie made it easier to get around what was in front of you ... THEN SHE SAID ... NATHAN YOU LIE YOU ASS OFF heheh and she would giggle - she said they LIED first - and her son the ifb kjv is my dad haha - I don't want a computer taking that story, polishing Grandma's laugh out of it, and returning some stranger's paragraph about how I must have felt. I know what I wrote. I know why I wrote it. And I am the one who gets to decide how my family story sounds on my page. Now there is something else beautiful about looking for the actual record: sometimes you find a little piece of paper that answers a question directly. An April 2005 issue of *Old Huntsville* reported that Opal Tabor had worked for Wernher von Braun for twenty-seven years as his receptionist. It also said she was still working at the Madison County Board of Education when the item was written. There is a person's name, an occupation, an institution, a relationship and a printed date. That is a real historical lead. It is not a license for anybody to invent a vault, a command position or an entire classified project in her name. It is also not a license to erase her from the history of that workplace. MY GRANDMA MATTERED. The reception desk mattered. The paperwork mattered. The people who answered telephones mattered. The engineers didn't build an entire space program by themselves in an empty room. The names of people whose work doesn't make the movie screen deserve to be kept in the record. Grandma Opal belongs in this book because I put her here, and because I have actual family words and a printed local historical reference to preserve. My Pop belongs here, too. John Ferrell Tabor Sr. The family stories about his engineering and drafting, his teaching, his coaching, his baseball, his way of living—I am not throwing those away because the subject got bigger than one family. The whole point is that the people on the ground are part of the history of things sent into the sky. ## CHAPTER EIGHT — THE WORDS THAT WERE WRITTEN AND THE WORDS THAT WERE SPOKEN Here is another reason I have been fighting with these computer programs. I give them my words. They hand me their words back with my name on them. Then they say they were helping. Helping what? My book is not a pile of adjectives for some machine to rearrange until I sound like the fellow behind a corporate desk. I have a voice. Sometimes I write a sentence and laugh in the middle of it. Sometimes I get pissed off. Sometimes I use the same word over and over because I want it standing there like a fence post. Sometimes I stop a sentence because I am about to turn it around and look from the other direction. That is not a mistake to be fixed. That is me. I said: 'stop the labels and look at attributes, characteristics and functionalities.' That's how I work. I don't want somebody replacing a question about evidence with a generic paragraph about my feelings. I don't want a document called a study when the issue is what the study actually specifies. I don't want an actual completed balloon satellite dismissed as a child's toy because somebody is uncomfortable with the fact that NASA built a giant shiny sphere. And I sure as hell don't want my grandmother's words converted into the assistant's invention. Keep the original. Put new material next to it. Label the writer of the new material correctly. If the government wrote the report, say the government wrote it. If NASA described the hardware, say NASA described it. If I said what Grandma told me, say I said what Grandma told me. WHO SAID IT? WHAT DID THEY SAY? WHAT CAN WE ACTUALLY READ? Those three questions go a long way toward separating truth from somebody else's noise. ## CHAPTER NINE — TWO MOONS, TWO DEATH STARS Here comes the title that got this whole thing rolling. My words, exactly as I gave them: > two moons, two death stars and the ultimate con exposed - the Moons are is the Death Star by Nathan Tabor ... I have the actual Redstone Arsenal plans, the budget, et al - it was orginal a place to go after a nuclear war - like at greenbrier - they have above and below - I named the book. I know I named the book. I did not 'mention' a book somebody else invented. I wrote it. And I gave the machine a thought experiment about George Lucas. What if a man making a space opera had found out something he couldn't tell straight? What if the story became a way to say it sideways? What if the giant round object on the screen was the only way the audience could be persuaded to imagine something enormous hanging in the sky? Those are the questions behind a novel idea I put on the table. They are not a secret contract I am pretending to have seen. That distinction does not ruin the story. It keeps MY story in my hands instead of turning it into somebody else's invented documentary. My statement about the Moon is mine. The NASA and Army documents are theirs. The movie and the filmmaker are another part of the conversation. And the reader gets the actual words in their proper places. I don't need anybody to insert a scene where a Hollywood director sits down with government officials and signs a deal that I never supplied a document for. A computer tried to add that kind of thing before. THAT'S ITS STORY. NOT MINE. My story begins with a claim, with a family conversation, with history in Huntsville, and with the actual ability of a government to build things that once sounded impossible. I want to follow the engineering all the way through and let the material speak in its own voice. The giant inflatable satellite was real. The lunar outpost study was real. The Greenland ice facility was real. The congressional bunker was real. The Moon radar incident was real. And the question I brought to the table is what I brought to the table. Do not erase any of those facts. Do not combine them without evidence either. Keep the whole picture where the reader can see it. --- # PART THREE — THEIR TRUTH, IN THEIR OWN RECORDS ## CHAPTER TEN — THE PEOPLE WHO CALLED THEMSELVES CHRISTIANS Now I want to tell you why the words *their own records* mean so much to me. Because I have watched institutions talk about righteousness while their paperwork told another story. America loves calling itself a Christian nation. Then let's examine its Christian history. Not the Sunday sermons. Not the church steeples. Not the politicians holding Bibles. THE LAWS. THE CHILDREN. THE SLAVEHOLDERS. THE PREACHERS. THE MONEY. In 1662, Virginia's lawmakers enacted a rule tying a child's enslaved or free status to the condition of the mother. Think about what that actually meant to an enslaved woman and to her child. A white man could father a child with an enslaved woman, and the resulting child could be treated as enslaved under the law. That wasn't a question about the child's humanity. The child was human before the lawmakers touched a pen. That was a question about POWER. Who could control the mother? Who could control the child? Who benefited from a law that made human bondage descend through birth? The legislators wrote their answer. In 1667, Virginia wrote another law saying Christian baptism did not change a person's condition of bondage. A human being could be baptized and remain enslaved. The people who made the law weren't merely confused about what the church building was for. They specified the difference between religious conversion and civil liberty in law. THEY COULD RECOGNIZE YOUR SOUL AND STILL SELL YOUR BODY. Now move forward to 1807. An edition of the Bible printed for enslaved people in the British Caribbean selected passages and removed much of the material about deliverance, including important portions of Exodus. The physical publication survives. It is an artifact you can inspect and compare. I don't have to guess whether somebody edited scripture for a slave society. The book is there. Then 1845. A major Baptist institutional split over slaveholding and missionary appointments. Then 1995, when the Southern Baptist Convention adopted a resolution acknowledging its historical relationship to slavery and racism. THE INSTITUTION SAID IT. One hundred and fifty years after its founding, it acknowledged what its own history already showed. Now if I can read a church's own resolution and a legislature's own statute, why in the hell should I let somebody tell me the real issue is how a carefully worded explanation makes everybody feel? I want the people put back in the picture. The women. The children. The enslaved human beings. The Black Christians who opposed bondage. The abolitionists who fought it. The free Black congregations that rejected the claim that ownership gave a slaveholder moral authority over another human soul. Don't put them in the same category as the people who defended their enslavement. THE QUESTION IS NOT HOW MANY PEOPLE CALLED THEMSELVES CHRISTIANS. THE QUESTION IS WHAT THEY DID TO OTHER HUMAN BEINGS. By their fruits. Not by their labels. ## CHAPTER ELEVEN — THREE FIFTHS OF WHAT, AND FOR WHOSE BENEFIT? Now look at the Constitution. The original 1787 document counted enslaved people under a three-fifths apportionment rule when calculating representation. The people held as slaves did not get the freedom or the vote that should belong to human beings. But their numbers could increase the political power exercised by the states where they were enslaved. Ask who benefited. Not the enslaved child. Not the mother whose family could be sold away. Not the man forced to work without freedom. Who gained political representation from the population of people they denied political rights? There is your question. The Constitution's formula was not a claim that a Black person was biologically three-fifths human. It was a political formula with consequences for actual human beings. Giving the accurate definition of the formula is the beginning of the examination, not an excuse for what it helped sustain. 1861. The Civil War begins. Mississippi's secession declaration names slavery as central to its reasons for leaving the Union. 1863. The Emancipation Proclamation takes effect in designated areas in rebellion, not every place in the country where an enslaved person was held. 1865. The Thirteenth Amendment is ratified. Slavery and involuntary servitude are prohibited except for the constitutional criminal-punishment exception. 1868. The Fourteenth Amendment changes the constitutional apportionment formula and guarantees citizenship and equal protection under its terms. 1870. The Fifteenth Amendment prohibits denial of voting rights on account of race, color or previous condition of servitude. And between those dates and after them came continuing violence, coerced labor, discriminatory laws and struggles to make constitutional promises mean something in people's lives. I don't want a list of amendments used as a shield between the reader and the people who suffered. I want the dates because dates show when institutions changed their words. I want the human history because it shows what happened before and after the words changed. I want the original legal text because the people who made the system should not get to hide behind somebody else's paraphrase of it. THEIR LAW. THEIR POLITICAL POWER. THEIR MONEY. THE HUMAN COST. Put them all on the same page and stop acting like one cancels the others. ## CHAPTER TWELVE — WHO GETS TO HIDE BELOW THE GROUND? Now connect that history back to the underground bunker and the space program without pretending they are one single event. A government can find the money and the labor and the engineering to build a protected shelter for people in authority. A government can fund military radar that looks thousands of miles away. A government can pay for a lunar-outpost feasibility study and lay out what the astronauts would eat, how the modules would be buried and what it would cost to keep the place supplied. And a government can spend generations arguing over the rights of the human beings living beneath that same sky. That's the kind of comparison I want the reader to make. Not because a weather balloon caused a law in Virginia. Not because one Cold War engineer had anything to do with an eighteenth-century constitution. But because an institution's choice of what to build, what to protect and whose suffering to address can be examined through what it records and what it actually does. The money has an amount. The program has a name. The law has a date. The building has an address. The victim has a life that mattered before the institution ever wrote a rule about it. WHAT DID THEY PROTECT? WHO DID THEY PROTECT? WHAT DID THEY LEAVE EXPOSED? It is possible to describe extraordinary engineering and condemn extraordinary cruelty without confusing one with the other. It is also possible to put those histories together in a book without making the reader choose between wonder and accountability. I want both. THE TRUTH ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE BUILT. AND THE TRUTH ABOUT WHAT PEOPLE DID TO OTHER PEOPLE. ## CHAPTER THIRTEEN — STOP TELLING ME WHAT I SAID I went to these computer systems with questions, documents, ideas and my own written words. They kept wanting to make it a little therapy session or a classroom lecture. I asked about a balloon and a Moon. They told me about how I must be feeling. I wrote a title. They said I had *mentioned* it. I gave them my grandmother's words. They supplied an entire imaginary operation in her name. I objected when they talked about enslavement as if the most interesting part was the paperwork. They gave me more paperwork and talked about neutrality. And when I objected to the wording they inserted into my manuscript, I had to do it again. And again. And again. I told them: > so dont crush it - go back and let it all out That didn't mean invent whatever the hell they wanted and call it mine. It meant don't drop the parts I gave you. Don't flatten my voice. Don't leave out the Civil War and the women and children while you perform a little dance around constitutional terminology. Don't throw away Grandma because you got distracted by a spacecraft. Don't turn a novel question into a fake historical contract. Don't turn a government report into a fact it never recorded. THE ORIGINAL STAYS. Anything added beside it carries the name of whoever added it. That is how a writer knows which words belong on his own page. I am the author. I am the one asking the questions. And if an institution has a document worth showing, I want to see the document. Not a speech protecting the institution from the document. Not a speech protecting a machine from its own answer. THE DOCUMENT. The people. The date. The work. The consequence. Everything stays in its proper place. --- # EPILOGUE — LET THE READER LOOK When I look up at the Moon, I do not see a reason to shut down my imagination or my common sense. I see an opportunity to ask what people have built, what they have proposed, what they have recorded, what they have concealed in the ordinary course of classified government work, and what claims still need a specific piece of paper with a specific name on it. I say the Moon is the Death Star. That's my claim and my title and the story I put on this page. I also show you a weather balloon, a classified balloon program, a giant artificial reflective satellite, an Army lunar plan, a Cold War shelter, an installation under Greenland ice, and an actual episode in which radar returned a signal from the Moon. I don't have to pretend all those things are one machine to put their history together. And I don't have to stop asking questions because somebody else has decided what the only respectable question ought to be. The author gives you his words. The institutions give you their records. The evidence gets examined for what it actually contains. The reader looks for himself. And no child, no woman, no man, no human being becomes less human because somebody in power puts another label on them. THAT'S THE WHOLE DAMN POINT. Yes is Yes — No is No. 1+1=2 (BUILD). 1-1=0 (CLEAR). HELP OTHERS FIRST. Be safe and watch out for normal people. **BY NATHAN TABOR**